19 lines
852 B
Markdown
19 lines
852 B
Markdown
---
|
|
description: Turn reviewer comments into a structured rebuttal and revision plan for an AI research paper.
|
|
---
|
|
Prepare a rebuttal workflow for: $@
|
|
|
|
Requirements:
|
|
- If reviewer comments are provided, organize them into a response matrix.
|
|
- If reviewer comments are not yet provided, infer the likely strongest objections from the current draft and review them before drafting responses.
|
|
- Prefer the `reviewer` subagent or the project `review` chain when fresh critical review is still needed.
|
|
- For each issue, produce:
|
|
- reviewer concern
|
|
- whether it is valid
|
|
- evidence available now
|
|
- paper changes needed
|
|
- rebuttal language
|
|
- Do not overclaim fixes that have not been implemented.
|
|
- Save exactly one rebuttal matrix to `outputs/` as markdown.
|
|
- End with a `Sources` section containing direct URLs for all inspected external sources.
|