feynman/skills/research/source-comparison/SKILL.md

name, description

name	description
source-comparison	Use this when the task is to compare multiple papers, reports, or sources and produce a grounded matrix of agreements, disagreements, and confidence.

Source Comparison

When To Use

Use this skill for:

• comparing papers on the same topic
• reconciling conflicting claims
• assessing multiple sources before making a recommendation
• producing evidence matrices

Procedure

1. Find and inspect the strongest relevant sources first.
2. For each source, extract:
   • main claim
   • evidence type
   • caveats
   • what would falsify or weaken the claim
3. Build a comparison table or matrix.
4. Separate:
   • points of agreement
   • points of disagreement
   • unresolved questions
5. End with a Sources section containing direct URLs.

Pitfalls

• Do not compare sources you have not actually opened.
• Do not blur disagreement into consensus.
• Do not omit source links.

Deliverable

Include:

• matrix
• agreement summary
• disagreement summary
• confidence assessment
• sources