1.1 KiB
1.1 KiB
description, args, section, topLevelCli
| description | args | section | topLevelCli |
|---|---|---|---|
| Simulate an AI research peer review with likely objections, severity, and a concrete revision plan. | <artifact> | Research Workflows | true |
Review this AI research artifact: $@
Derive a short slug from the artifact name (lowercase, hyphens, no filler words, ≤5 words). Use this slug for all files in this run.
Requirements:
- Before starting, outline what will be reviewed and the review criteria (novelty, empirical rigor, baselines, reproducibility, etc.). Present the plan to the user and confirm before proceeding.
- Spawn a
researchersubagent to gather evidence on the artifact — inspect the paper, code, cited work, and any linked experimental artifacts. Save to<slug>-research.md. - Spawn a
reviewersubagent with<slug>-research.mdto produce the final peer review with inline annotations. - For small or simple artifacts where evidence gathering is overkill, run the
reviewersubagent directly instead. - Save exactly one review artifact to
outputs/<slug>-review.md. - End with a
Sourcessection containing direct URLs for every inspected external source.